Looseness
I’ve been working on a new script recently, with an eye to shoot something quickly and cheaply, and have been thinking a lot about looseness. Looseness not only in how I write, but in how I conceive the entire process: casting, running the set, and especially the performances. It’s really about shifting where a film is coming from in me, from my interest in the craft, aesthetics and logistics of filmmaking (which is primarily where my first two films came from) to the expression of story, performance, behavior, and — for lack of a less overused word — truth.
A number of quotes from various filmmakers have helped me articulate what I’m after with this new film, and I’ve included a few below. The modern-day genre most closely resembling what I’m thinking of is Mumblecore, which is just another point on a long continuum where filmmakers commit to making inexpensive personal films they control creatively, with the goal of capturing naturalistic performances.
This is a thread that goes through the French New Wave, the American New Wave of the 70’s, the films of Cassavetes, Neorealism… For me, all of these share one thing in common: They strive to create a sense of reality with recognizable human behavior. And in an age where empty sequels, TV show remakes, comic book and horror films dominate the landscape, I believe it’s actually what audiences are hungry for, or at least the audience I’m interested in.
And now, the quotes:
Sam Mendes, on changing up his approach on Away We Go, especially after the experience of directing Revolutionary Road:
“I was intent on letting people breathe in the frame a little bit more. Revolutionary was like trying to hold the viewers in a vice, and the actors, too. It was tense and claustrophobic and extremely rigid in the framing. [Away We Go] is quite classically done in the sense that it’s very simply made, but the playfulness that’s there is because I wasn’t overly strict about how we were staging things.”
“I’ve just stumbled on something I think that’s probably quite true. What happened, I think, is it’s very easy when you’re a filmmaker to let the process lead you and not the material, not the actors. So you’ve got to get 17 setups in the day, and you’ve got to shoot this when the sun’s this high, and you’ve got to get out of here by 8:00 because tomorrow we’ve got a new location, and before you know it, you’re making a schedule and not making a movie. And I think that didn’t happen here, which is nice.”
“[Regarding rehearsal and pre-production], you want to fill people with as many ideas as possible, but without ever making them do it. Fill the gas tank with as much gas as you can, but never turn the ignition key. Because otherwise what happens is exactly that—they end up doing it well, because they’re all good, and then thinking when they come to shoot it eight weeks later, ‘What did we do?’ They’re trying to remember a performance, as opposed to just giving a performance.”
Milos Forman on making One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest:
“In Cuckoo’s Nest, the superintendent was a real superintendent of a mental hospital, a nonprofessional actor, and for his scene with Jack Nicholson I told him, ‘Just do your job with Jack, as a psychiatrist.’ And I told Jack, ‘Just react to what you hear from the doctor. Okay, let’s shoot it.’ We did maybe four takes, and cut the scene from the best moments. When you do it that way, you can get gems, unrepeatable moments. It gives so much real life to the scene. That’s what you want to get on film, unrepeatable moments.”
Michel Gondry on directing actors:
“You don’t want your actors to get too comfortable. Because that’s when the shtick comes. If an actor doesn’t have time to think, they cannot do whatever they are used to doing. The visual must be predetermined, but the emotion can’t be.”
Steven Soderbergh on his shift to a looser approach in his film Traffic:
“This is not about perfection, I don’t want to give people marks; I don’t want them thinking about that stuff. You don’t want them thinking. You want them being.”







